How many backlinks do I need for my website?

This is the #1 question we get from new clients at The HOTH. 

The only problem is it’s essentially an impossible question, as there’s no magic number of backlinks that every site needs. 

In fact, asking this question is on par with other impossible questions like, “How many licks does it take to get to the center of a Tootsie Pop?” and, “How much wood could a woodchuck chuck if a woodchuck could chuck wood?

A freeze frame from the classic Tootsie Pop commercial with the owl and a young boy.

When most SEOs get this question, they all say the same thing:

“It depends.”

We think that’s pretty lame, and we’re sick of hearing it. 

That’s why we’re going to do the impossible and attempt to answer this borderline rhetorical question

Along the way, you’ll learn more about the current state of backlinks as a ranking factor, as well as some up-to-date techniques for generating high-quality links that point to your homepage and content. 

Do Links Still Matter? Addressing Google’s Recent Comments

In September 2023, Gary Illyes, an Analyst on Google’s Search Team, claimed during an AMA that ‘links were no longer a top 3 ranking factor, and haven’t been for some time.’

This caused some to think that backlinks no longer mattered at all, which isn’t true. 

Here’s his quote: “I think they are important, but I think people overestimate the importance of links. I don’t agree it’s in the top three. It hasn’t been for some time.”

Illyes didn’t say that backlinks had no ranking power, as he still said they’re important. 

Beyond that, there’s good reason to take Illyes’ words with a grain of salt. 

Why is that?

It’s because Google is always a bit cagey when disclosing information about their search algorithms. It’s not that they outright lie per se, just that they have a habit of bending the truth and omitting key pieces of information. 

It’s the same reason why they don’t make their PageRank algorithm public, as they feel too many businesses would game the system for better SERP rankings. 

Google’s ultimate goal is to provide the best search experience for its users, which means matching their queries with the highest quality results that come from trusted, authoritative sources. 

Therefore, Google has a bit of a love/hate relationship with SEO. 

They know that it’s necessary for businesses to improve their visibility on their engine, but their SEO advice seldom goes beyond ‘make better content.’

Proof backlinks are still the real deal 

Take it from us: backlinks still matter in a very big way. 

Perfect technical SEO and flawless on-page factors will only get you so far. 

Whenever we have a client that can’t outrank its competitors, links are almost always the reason why.

Since the websites occupying the top-ranking spots have more high-quality links than our clients’ sites, outranking them with basic SEO tactics is next to impossible. 

As a result, we spend the most time ‘closing the competitive gap’ by building enough links for our clients to level the playing field with their top competitors. 

The fact remains that more links equal better SERP rankings AND more organic traffic, which is why high-value links are so powerful (they’re literally working double duty for you).

To put our money where our mouth is, here’s hard evidence from one of our clients that backlinks and traffic go hand-in-hand:

 A screenshot of a HOTH client’s SEO success.

As you can see by the line graphs, as the client’s backlinks started to increase, their organic traffic followed suit. 

The lesson?

You should always believe the hard data you collect from your own experiments and campaigns over comments from Google’s team regarding SEO.

Other Crucial Ranking Factors 

While links are still extremely important for Google SEO, they’re by no means the only ranking factor. 

As we said before, building more links is what bridges the competitive gap for our clients most of the time. However, if their technical and on-page factors aren’t also in perfect order, it won’t be possible to reach the top of the SERPs. 

To summarize, for backlinks to show their true power, other crucial ranking factors like site speed need to be up to par; otherwise, you may not even rank. 

Let’s be clear: the #1 most important ranking factor is the quality and relevance of your content. 

If you aren’t producing high-quality content that satisfies user’s search intent, your hopes of becoming the SEO GOAT will never come to fruition. 

Moreover, the quality and relevance of your content are also extremely important to your target audience, and you should always produce content for them first and search engines second. 

Here’s a look at the top SERP ranking factors besides backlinks and content:

  • SSL certificate (HTTPS for a secure web browsing experience) 
  • Adequate site speed to pass Google’s Core Web Vitals test 
  • Content length (Google views pages with less than approximately 1,000 words as thin content) 
  • Keyword usage (first 100 words, title tag, headers) 
  • URL and site architecture (logical, flat design with lots of internal links) 
  • Content must load properly on mobile devices (Google uses mobile-first indexing) 
  • External links (content should link out to reputable sources) 
  • Content quality via E-E-A-T (experience, expertise, authoritativeness, trustworthiness) 

Image of Google Logo on Plate and Google E-E-A-T

These factors are all imperative for SEO success, so you shouldn’t neglect any of them during your search campaign. 

The Classic Debate: Quantity vs. Quality 

SEOs are always fiercely debating whether backlink quality or quantity matters most. 

Some swear that only the most reputable, highest-quality backlinks are worth pursuing, while others claim to find success by building as many links as possible. 

Which side of the issue is true?

We hate to be boring, but the truth of the matter is both quantity and quality are of equal importance to your link profile

Let’s clarify that a bit further. 

In terms of quantity, it’s NEVER worth pursuing low-grade backlinks from garbage websites that provide no value to users. 

These links scream spam to Google, and they’ll only hurt your SERP rankings. 

However, when you’re trying to bridge a significant link gap between you and a competitor (where you have dozens of links and they have hundreds or thousands), sometimes links with average domain authority (scores 40 to 50) are exactly what you need. 

These average links are still from real websites that provide services to users, so there’s no worry about them getting flagged as spam. 

Moreover, they’ll provide you with the volume of links you need to catch up to the competition. 

In other words, beggars can’t be choosers when you’re far behind in the backlink race. 

That’s not to say that you shouldn’t shoot for the stars and target high-value backlinks (DA scores 60 and above) at the same time, as you definitely should. 

Conversely, if you’re practically on par with the number of links a competitor has, then going for high-quality links is the name of the game. 

Ultimately, it depends on what you’re trying to achieve. If you’re far behind, quantity can beat quality – but if you’re neck-and-neck, quality reigns supreme. 

How Many Backlinks Do New Websites Need?

If you’ve got a brand-spanking-new website, you’re starting from square one in terms of backlinks. 

The same is also true for all SEO ranking factors. 

Before you start pursuing backlinks full-time, you should get your technical SEO and on-page SEO in order. 

That means doing things like planning out your URL structure and site architecture, doing keyword research to inform your content strategy, and ensuring your site is mobile-friendly and has an SSL certificate (it’s remarkably easy to get an SSL certificate for free). 

Also, you need to start populating your new site with lots of stellar content based on queries that your target audience searches for the most (you can use our free keyword planner tool for this). 

The Hoth's Google Keyword Planner Tool

Don’t forget to include content for each stage of your sales funnel based on the intent behind the keywords you find

Once that’s all set, you can start building links for your site, but how many do you need?

On average, you should shoot for 50 links pointing to your homepage and around 100 for each web page that you want to rank

Drop anchor! Achieving the proper anchor text ratio 

Besides the links themselves, the anchor text you choose for each link is also incredibly important. 

Anchor text refers to the words that you use to display a hyperlink, and there are a few ways you can go about it:

  • Exact match anchors consist entirely of the target keyword for the page in question. You should use these anchors sparingly, as Google views too many as spam. 
  • Partial match anchors contain your target keyword as well as a few other phrases to add context. It’s a safer bet to use partial match keyword anchors instead of an exact match. 
  • Branded anchors use your brand name as a link. 
  • Natural anchors don’t use any keywords or brand names, just natural words in the sentence containing the link. 
  • Naked URLs don’t use any anchor text in favor of using a bare URL. 

For your backlink profile to achieve its maximum impact, it needs to feature a favorable anchor text ratio

For the most part, you should use exact match anchors sparingly while opting for partial match, branded, and natural anchors most of the time. 

How Do You Get Backlinks?

By now, you should have a specific number of backlinks you need to build. 

To reiterate what we’ve covered so far:

  • Analyze your competitor’s links to see how large of a gap there is between their link profile and yours. If it’s large, going for quantity over quality can work until you start to catch up. If it’s small, your goal should be to obtain as many high-value links as possible. 
  • If you’re working with a brand-new website, aim for 50 links to your homepage, with around 100 links for your most important web pages. 

Now that we’ve answered the titular question of this article, another one remains. 

How do you build links that point back to your content?

Here’s a look at some of the most effective ways to acquire backlinks. 

Reach out and touch someone: targeted link outreach 

Conducting outreach is necessary for just about any backlink technique, and it’s become more nuanced in recent years. 

In the past, SEOs found success using generic outreach templates that contained simple requests for guest articles, link insertions, and fixing broken links. 

The only problem is this technique worked a little too well. 

Once it caught on, it became the norm (and still is) for website owners to receive hundreds of generic outreach emails every day. 

Currently, the link outreach game is about standing out from the crowd while developing long-lasting relationships that lead to multiple links down the line

It’s crucial to shift your mindset from targeting one link at a time to forging long-term link partnerships with related websites in your field. 

Also, divorce the link outreach process from one particular tactic, such as guest posting. 

When done properly, your outreach can lead to a lot more than guest blogs (although those are pretty sweet, too). 

As an example scenario, let’s say that your website sells fitness products. 

In that case, you’d benefit from forming link partnerships with noncompetitors in your field – meaning you share a target audience but don’t compete for the same business. 

Examples include fitness news websites, fitness forums, and nutrition blogs – just to name a few. 

Instead of sending one-and-done outreach emails, you start interacting with these sites in a far more personal way. Your goal is to form a relationship instead of securing one measly link placement, so you should interact with their social media, ask interesting questions, and share their content. 

If you play your cards right, you’ll form a partnership that leads to guest posts, link insertions, and article syndications. 

Press releases and article syndication 

Speaking of syndication, you can start publishing your articles on other websites to gain more exposure and accrue links. 

Relationship building is a key component here, too, as you’ll need an existing network of relevant websites to publish your articles. 

If you don’t have any connections yet, try searching on Google for things like:

  • “Originally published on” (niche keyword)
  • “Syndicated from” (niche keyword)
  • “Originally appeared on” (niche keyword)

These search operators will help you find websites in your field that syndicate posts and it’s worth trying to build relationships with them. 

You can also use our free backlink checker tool to analyze your competitor’s links to see if they’re syndicated anywhere that you aren’t. 

Press releases (as long as they don’t mention time-sensitive events) are another great way to get the word out about your brand and obtain links. 

This is where it pays off to have relationships with news outlets in your niche, as you’ll be able to circulate your press releases to them for some easy links. 

To further your education, here are some more reliable ways to build backlinks from relevant websites

Start Building the Right Number of Links Today 

Well, wasn’t that a much better answer than simply saying, “It depends?”

Now, you have an accurate approximation of how many links you need to build to achieve your ranking goals, and you know the best ways to build them. 

This is only the first step in your journey to becoming the SERP GOAT, so stay tuned to our blog for more practical advice. 

If you need help building the right number of links for your website, don’t wait to check out our Link Outreach and Link Insertion services.